The Assassin's Creed 3 Reviews Thread [SPOILERS] | Forums

[ACfan443]

Well said my friend .
I mean look at this list .
10/10 - Xbox 360 Magazine (Italy)
10/10 -
10/10 - Digital Spy
10/10 - PlayStation LifeStyle
5/5 - Hardcore Gamer
5/5 - G4
5/5 - Game Revolution
9.75/10 - Shortandsweetreviews.co
9.5/10 - EGM
9.5/10 - GameInformer
9.5/10 - PS3Gen.fr
9.2/10 - Gametrailers
9.2/10 - Gamezone.de
92/100 - Gamepro.de
91/100 - Electronic Theatre
9/10 - Eurogamer
9/10 - Strategy Informer
9/10 - Play3.de
9/10 - .com
9/10 - X360 Magazine
9/10 - Golden4Games.com
88/100 - PC Games
8.5/10 - IGN
8.5 - GameSpot
8.5/10 - Gamesaktuell.de
8.5/10 - Meristation
8/10 - CVG
8/10 - GamesRadar
8/10 - Polygon
80/100 - 4players.de
79/100 - Gamesbeat
7.5/10 - Destructoid
7/10 - OPM
There are a lot of magazines that gave the game a full mark ,, If you find IGN review funny
You should go see Machinma Review you will laugh you a** off !
they can't review for sh*t !!

Ordering the list like that makes it seem slightly better, but it's really annoying to see the major companies giving it the lowest score. I'll just prepare myself for machinima's review *cracks knuckles*

[POP1Fan]

Does anyone care about IGN anymore? They haven't been a serious reviwer since 2008.

[KarimMusa]

Does anyone care about IGN anymore? They haven't been a serious reviwer since 2008.

I don't care about them ,,,, the same thing happened to AC2 right? but It's one of the best Games I have ever played in my entire life !
But giving AC3 an 8.5 ? This Sh*t have gone too far !

[POP1Fan]

I don't care about them ,,,, the same thing happened to AC2 right? but It's one of the best Games I have ever played in my entire life !
But giving AC3 an 8.5 ? This Sh*t have gone too far !

I agree. It's hard to make guys who give 10 out of 10 to games where you just run around and shoot stuff and make them play games with complex stories and different gameplay and also make them enjoy it. This game is great. Screw whatever any reviwer says about it.

[ACfan443]

I don't care about them ,,,, the same thing happened to AC2 right? but It's one of the best Games I have ever played in my entire life !
But giving AC3 an 8.5 ? This Sh*t have gone too far !

They're getting quite a few dislikes and angry comments on their youtube review. Serves them right.

[KarimMusa]

They're getting quite a few dislikes and angry comments on their youtube review. Serves them right.

This game is Great ,, I think it will get GOTY (I haven't got the game till now xD) Getting it tomorrow ... WOO!

[FirestarLuva]

"Connor isn't as straightforwardly charming as Assassin's Creed II's Ezio, and although writing is excellent for the most part, you never warm to Assassin’s Creed III’s heroes nor grow to resent its villains in quite the same way." IGN

WHAT!??? AC3 had the best villian in the game and main character. DX

[NOLA_Assassin]

Well said my friend .
I mean look at this list .
10/10 - Xbox 360 Magazine (Italy)
10/10 -
10/10 - Digital Spy
10/10 - PlayStation LifeStyle
5/5 - Hardcore Gamer
5/5 - G4
5/5 - Game Revolution
9.75/10 - Shortandsweetreviews.co
9.5/10 - EGM
9.5/10 - GameInformer
9.5/10 - PS3Gen.fr
9.2/10 - Gametrailers
9.2/10 - Gamezone.de
92/100 - Gamepro.de
91/100 - Electronic Theatre
9/10 - Eurogamer
9/10 - Strategy Informer
9/10 - Play3.de
9/10 - .com
9/10 - X360 Magazine
9/10 - Golden4Games.com
88/100 - PC Games
8.5/10 - IGN
8.5 - GameSpot
8.5/10 - Gamesaktuell.de
8.5/10 - Meristation
8/10 - CVG
8/10 - GamesRadar
8/10 - Polygon
80/100 - 4players.de
79/100 - Gamesbeat
7.5/10 - Destructoid
7/10 - OPM
There are a lot of magazines that gave the game a full mark ,, If you find IGN review funny
You should go see Machinma Review you will laugh your a** off !
they can't review for sh*t !!

Destructoid also lost all credibility with their ridiculous Re 6 review.
And IGN has always been inconsistent with their reviews. They gave COD BO an 8.5 but it gave MW3 a 9 when BO was so much better.

Edit: They also gave AC 2 an 9.2, I think AC 3 should've been higher...

[RinoTheBouncer]

The whole game deserves 200/100 because 100/100 would be just fulfilling all standards while 200/100 means it's distinguished from any other game. The only disadvantage is the ending. After playing AC games for years waiting for this moment, we literally expected an epic ending and we have every right to do so as such epic game deserves an epic ending not just so rushed and pointless twist.

[tarrero]

1 This game has WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY more side quests and replay value than any other AC, heck even freeroaming is more enjoyable.
2 The platforming levels feel more carefully done, and thus, better. at least to me.
3 Connor´s story has pretty cool plot twists.
4 The missions vary from classical stealth/combat to HUGE "epic" warfare stuff, and LOVE that.
5 Graphics are improved.

The not so good:
1 Although Desmond´s quest is better than before, I had higher expectations.
2 Connor´s main story could be a little bit longer, mostly if you take into account how big is the "building" part of it.

The "ugly"
The "cosmetic plot twist" though hehe, hope it can be glitched.

This game deserves at least a 9, I would give it a 9.5 still.