1. #1
    Just in case no one has heard this, I am holding the latest issue of CGW, arguably the nations oldest and most respected computer gaming mag. (I've been a subscriber since 1982)
    Ahem... In a series of selected game reviews
    SH3 was awarded 5 out of 5 stars with these comments: "Silent Hunter III is destined to be a Sim Hall of Fame all-time classic."

    I know some of you may have mixed feelings about this, but personally, I'm glad to see it, and I think it is a good call.
    Share this post

  2. #2
    I am very pleased to see the way that the main stream mags have taken to SHIII and for the good reviews.
    Share this post

  3. #3
    It's only taken the gaming press two months to figure out that this is the best game of the year. I mean they must have had copies before the public got hold of it in March, yet they failed to get a review out until now (???). I just got PC Gamer today and they rate it at 90% and make it their editor's choice game. That's great, but it would have been far more useful if the review had been available closer to the release date.

    Let's face it, the press dropped the ball on this one. I mean the press is supposed to give us 'news'. This news is over six weeks old. That's not 'new' even by 19th century standards. The mail in the Victorian age could have got these 'news' from Europe (where the game was developed) to me here in the US faster than the 21st century electronic gaming press did.
    Share this post

  4. #4
    Charlie901's Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Posts
    1,204
    Originally posted by Beeryus:
    It's only taken the gaming press two months to figure out that this is the best game of the year. I mean they must have had copies before the public got hold of it in March, yet they failed to get a review out until now (???). I just got PC Gamer today and they rate it at 90% and make it their editor's choice game. That's great, but it would have been far more useful if the review had been available closer to the release date.

    Let's face it, the press dropped the ball on this one. I mean the press is supposed to give us 'news'. This news is over six weeks old. That's not 'new' even by 19th century standards. The mail in the Victorian age could have got these 'news' from Europe (where the game was developed) to me here in the US faster than the 21st century electronic gaming press did.


    Isn't it funny now that SHIII is such a sales success, the mainstream gaming magazines are NOW jumping on the bandwagon. Sheeezzz!
    Share this post

  5. #5
    In fairness, CGW did do a priliminary review on sh3 in their Feb issue. The information was limited, but covered most of the features we are now familiar with. I started focusing on it at that point. They alluded at the time that they had good feelings about it, but it is not clear whether they had a beta in their possession as of that writing.
    Share this post