🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The Division forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game
  1. #31
    Originally Posted by Ranger_Logan Go to original post
    There are enough posts on this forum from you in which you start attacking someone else & end up in some wannabe moral high ground in which you want to appear as analytical, neutral & fair. Please respect your own advice: treat others the way you want to be treated. Because the way you treat others, according to your own posts, this forum would've had the highest numbers of banned users.You seriously take things too personal, honestly!
    I am guilty of that myself several times in which I've been annoyed enough to act in such a way, I don't deny that -- needlessly towards you a couple of times, but I don't agree fully with what you are saying, since you make it, as If I am constantly doing that, which is simply not true. Thing is my opinion and views rarely align with those of others in here, but I rarely post with the intention to openly attack others. I can't control how others read into my post however, but most of the time it's simply me disagreeing with something and I have had my fair share of being attacked, because of my different opinion and views. But, no. I really don't take things too personally. In the end of the day it's the internet.
    Share this post

  2. #32
    Originally Posted by ginto76 Go to original post
    rofl.

    I live 10 minutes walk from a big UBIsoft studio in the south of France, I can airbnb you a room for a premium if you want to go get a job there as janitor.
    Oh look.... speaking of being attacked, because of my different opinion. What a surprise, eh? No, thank you. I have pretty profitable job. Maybe you should look for that offer instead, since you live nearby anyhow.
    Share this post

  3. #33
    Dude, I'm not feeling attacked, I literally laughed my butt off reading your crap.

    This being said, regardless of what you think is a one shot or this guy think it is, like one or two people pointed out in the thread already, you're not helping people stay in the game by threatening and harassing people who come here frustrated by the one shot too-fast-to-react mechanics some of the lower tier mobs in this game have.
    The dev team even acknowledged this, so I might ask; why not instead of harassing this frustrated player calling him a troll and wanting proof, you don't just redirect him to the last STOG?

    Who's the troll already?
    Share this post

  4. #34
    Originally Posted by dagrommit Go to original post
    I was referring to the OP. He was the one who claimed this happened with no evidence. Having said that, the same applies to you. You can either help identify how to reproduce the problem, or you can whine about it when it doesn't get fixed. Your choice.

    I am doubtful about how extensive your QA experience is. All developers (not just games) require details to consistently reproduce a bug before they can fix it, especially as QA never covers 100% of scenarios (anyone in QA who claims otherwise is a liar).

    I can think of plenty of details that might be relevant - was the OP on a server outside of their region? Was there more than one NPC shooting at them? How much armor and health did they actually have (as opposed to claimed)? Were they ensnared, shocked or affected by some other status effect? What damage was inflicted as per the death screen? Were they in a group, and how big was it?

    Compare that to "one-shotted by a red bar on hard"
    Man, I'm glad I did my QA period in a time when they actually demanded performance. Ok, so it seems I don't have what it takes to be in QA... nowadays.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Xv0WguFTFE&t=388s
    The first 20sec of this video shows a wonderful tool that they use. Back in my day we nicknamed it "Worldbuilders". From what I see in that video is that they can set up as fast as they want & test anything in all manners. With a tool like that at my hand I could've tested the OP's scenario with all levels of armor against all types of AI. I wouldn't need a video. Actually, what he said would be enough for me.

    ...as If I am constantly doing that, which is simply not true...
    True, friend. My mistake for saying "enough". That was rude of me. My apologies!
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  5. #35
    Originally Posted by ginto76 Go to original post
    Dude, I'm not feeling attacked, I literally laughed my butt off reading your crap.

    This being said, regardless of what you think is a one shot or this guy think it is, like one or two people pointed out in the thread already, you're not helping people stay in the game by threatening and harassing people who come here frustrated by the one shot too-fast-to-react mechanics some of the lower tier mobsin this game have.
    The dev team even acknowledged this, so I might ask; why not instead of harassing this frustrated player, you don't just redirect him to the last STOG instead of calling him a troll and wanting proof?

    Who's the troll already?
    Well I've never been one shot in this game. Never. EVER and I've been playing it for a while. Not from an Elite, Not from a Named and certainly not from a red and I play Heroic exclusively at the moment, so claiming you are getting ONE SHOT from RED on Hard with 1.9m is just pure BS and off the chance it actually happened it's probably a bug that will happen once every 100 missions or something. Laugh it up all you like, I really don't care.
    Share this post

  6. #36
    dagrommit's Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Pedestal of truth
    Posts
    5,099
    Originally Posted by Ranger_Logan Go to original post
    Man, I'm glad I did my QA period in a time when they actually demanded performance. Ok, so it seems I don't have what it takes to be in QA... nowadays.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Xv0WguFTFE&t=388s
    The first 20sec of this video shows a wonderful tool that they use. Back in my day we nicknamed it "Worldbuilders". From what I see in that video is that they can set up as fast as they want & test anything in all manners. With a tool like that at my hand I could've tested the OP's scenario with all levels of armor against all types of AI.
    Go reread my post. Armor was just one factor, and I didn't even include other factors like whether they were in cover, what that cover was, or whether they were weakened due to having died recently. Also, Ubi's tool still requires someone script the AI to play through a mission in a specific way - and taking the same path and actions as the player. Even then, as the game spawns different enemies for a given encounter, an automated run isn't necessarily going to reproduce the circumstances in which this supposedly happened.

    I'll say it for the last time. If you want a bug fixed, provide as much detail as possible in the hope it gets prioritized as something that can be reproduced. Or just continue to whine when it doesn't get fixed
    Share this post

  7. #37
    Originally Posted by dagrommit Go to original post
    Go reread my post. Armor was just one factor, and I didn't even include other factors like whether they were in cover, what that cover was, or whether they were weakened due to having died recently. Also, Ubi's tool still requires someone script the AI to play through a mission in a specific way - and taking the same path and actions as the player. Even then, as the game spawns different enemies for a given encounter, an automated run isn't necessarily going to reproduce the circumstances in which this supposedly happened.

    I'll say it for the last time. If you want a bug fixed, provide as much detail as possible in the hope it gets prioritized as something that can be reproduced. Or just continue to whine when it doesn't get fixed
    Like I said... for me! Which you cut out from quoting...

    I read every bit of a comment. I admit, I was lazy in detailing my post. But what I wanted to state about armor is that I would've determined the all types of damage done to armor (distance, which weapon, under/out of status effect, inside/outside cover, cover2cover/running/sprinting/walking, weapons, talents, with/without CHC+CHD, headshot, etc.).

    Edit: You should reread when I actually mention "against all types of AI".
    Share this post

  8. #38
    willyvic's Avatar Moderator
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Suisun City, CA
    Posts
    3,353
    I have been "one shotted" and have had my armor obliterated and my health bar taken to a sliver. This by all levels of NPC on all difficulty levels of the map. Surprises the heck out of me when it's done by a red. I have come to suspect the armor system scales the npc response/damage. I put on 850,000, they hit for 848,000. I put on 1.2 milliion, they hit for 1.19 million, etc...lol. It appears, to me, that armor level just don't matter...

    WV
    Share this post

  9. #39
    Originally Posted by Deathlyhearts Go to original post
    See if this is how OP presented his issue my response would be completely different. It's not my job to go digging around forums and reddits for things like this. It's OP job to provide evidence to support his claims. Calling anyone who will disagree with his word alone trolls is certainly not the proper approach. Not to mention that a topic like this have 99% chance of being ignored by the people who actually have the power to help out with those issues. So either bother yourself enough to make your case properly or don't post at all IMO.
    Lol...”not my job”...hilarious. You act as if every post critical of the game is addressed to you. No, it’s not your job but you act as if it is your job to monitor the forums and attack anyone who is critical. Must be exhausting being the self-appointed apologist for this game. When do you find the time to actually play?
     5 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  10. #40
    Originally Posted by ziljn Go to original post
    Lol...”not my job”...hilarious. You act as if every post critical of the game is addressed to you. No, it’s not your job but you act as if it is your job to monitor the forums and attack anyone who is critical. Must be exhausting being the self-appointed apologist for this game. When do you find the time to actually play?
    You really should learn what different opinion is and what public forum means and what's it's purpose. But hey must be exhausting to be hating on a video game all the time and picking fights with anyone who disagree with you. Also it's no concern of yours what I do with my time, you feel me?
    Share this post