🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The For Honor forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game
  1. #21
    KitingFatKidsEZ's Avatar Banned
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    340
    Minion executions were a terrible game mechanic. People hate change thats all. Hard to fundamentally do any change after a full release.

    At this point if these were in the game and i would see someone use these to clear rather than their other - better options, i would report them for griefing/afk.

    Impactful attacks are nice and all but not if they stand in the way of gameplay.
    Share this post

  2. #22
    Originally Posted by KitingFatKidsEZ Go to original post
    Minion executions were a terrible game mechanic. People hate change thats all. Hard to fundamentally do any change after a full release.

    At this point if these were in the game and i would see someone use these to clear rather than their other - better options, i would report them for griefing/afk.

    Impactful attacks are nice and all but not if they stand in the way of gameplay.
    No, people don't always hate change.
    And if the executions were there, you could simply switch to guard mode if you don't like them. It's that simple.
     3 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  3. #23
    Originally Posted by KitingFatKidsEZ Go to original post
    Minion executions were a terrible game mechanic. People hate change thats all. Hard to fundamentally do any change after a full release.

    At this point if these were in the game and i would see someone use these to clear rather than their other - better options, i would report them for griefing/afk.

    Impactful attacks are nice and all but not if they stand in the way of gameplay.
    The animations speed can always be sped up. Then again, some people including me like to enjoy every detail in the game. You just clearly want to play to win and that's why you're against it, simply go on guard mode and clear minions if it bothers you this much but let others who like it, enjoy it with its details.
    Share this post

  4. #24
    I'm guessing the people who don't want them back play only PvP
    Share this post

  5. #25
    Bring minion animations back but have them cost STEEL to unlock. This way people who don't want them, don't have to buy them (and have an option to toggle them on/off before a match) I believe the reason they took them out based on Freeze's video is MONEY.



    To Compromise & Make Everyone Happy
    Implement prices for each animation chain. That means:

    1) Light, Light, Light (3000 Steel)
    2) Heavy, Heavy, Heavy (3000 steel)
    3) Light, Heavy, Heavy (3000 steel)
    4) Light, Heavy, Light (3000 Steel)
    5) Light, Light, Heavy (3000 steel)
    6) Heavy, Light, Light (3000 steel)
    7) Heavy, Light, Heavy (3000 Steel)
    8) Heavy, Heavy, Light (3000 Steel)
    9) Buy all animation chains at once (20,000 Steel)
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  6. #26
    Originally Posted by Lord.Warden. Go to original post
    Bring minion animations back but have them cost STEEL to unlock. This way people who don't want them, don't have to buy them (and have an option to toggle them on/off before a match) I believe the reason they took them out based on Freeze's video is MONEY.



    To Compromise & Make Everyone Happy
    Implement prices for each animation chain. That means:

    1) Light, Light, Light (3000 Steel)
    2) Heavy, Heavy, Heavy (3000 steel)
    3) Light, Heavy, Heavy (3000 steel)
    4) Light, Heavy, Light (3000 Steel)
    5) Light, Light, Heavy (3000 steel)
    6) Heavy, Light, Light (3000 steel)
    7) Heavy, Light, Heavy (3000 Steel)
    8) Heavy, Heavy, Light (3000 Steel)
    9) Buy all animation chains at once (20,000 Steel)
    That is the best option I see
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  7. #27
    Originally Posted by UbiYubble Go to original post
    Just to spark up a conversation: what did you all love about the minion kill animations? If they're not put back in, what kind of alternative would you want to see added?
    I figured the main issue with the slow clear of minion animations might have been that you always target the minion closest to you with the maximum range of your attack. This is still the case now unless in lockon mode (Addition here: If you auto-lockon to an enemy hero/commander/etc. it becomes almost impossible to hit the minions around you).

    And of course the way minions clump around you, and I have not yet found all rules they do or don't to this by, plays an important role in clearing as well.

    But placing minion kill animations back in the game for light attacks, at about the speed that the hero's actual light attacks have, should be in order. You could kill around 2 to 3 minions with an animation back then, and that is still the maximum now.
    The heavy attacks that are used for clearing should remain without animation to grant the faster clear they currently have.
    Share this post

  8. #28
    Originally Posted by Gunthaarr Go to original post
    I figured the main issue with the slow clear of minion animations might have been that you always target the minion closest to you with the maximum range of your attack. This is still the case now unless in lockon mode (Addition here: If you auto-lockon to an enemy hero/commander/etc. it becomes almost impossible to hit the minions around you).

    And of course the way minions clump around you, and I have not yet found all rules they do or don't to this by, plays an important role in clearing as well.

    But placing minion kill animations back in the game for light attacks, at about the speed that the hero's actual light attacks have, should be in order. You could kill around 2 to 3 minions with an animation back then, and that is still the maximum now.
    The heavy attacks that are used for clearing should remain without animation to grant the faster clear they currently have.
    Back then you could also clear lots of minions with a heavy attack
    Share this post

  9. #29
    Gaser.'s Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2019
    Posts
    1,455
    Originally Posted by The...DEvil Go to original post
    Back then you could also clear lots of minions with a heavy attack
    With what hero? (there are only like two heroes who had better clearing with the animation, the rest was fast with lock on attacks)
    Share this post

  10. #30
    Originally Posted by The...DEvil Go to original post
    No, people don't always hate change.
    And if the executions were there, you could simply switch to guard mode if you don't like them. It's that simple.
    I'm glad I'm not the only one who knows that 'workaround'.
    Share this post