🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The For Honor forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game
  1. #1

    Improving how gear and perks work

    This post is accepting that gear stats is gone and finding a way forward to improve how things work. Please take "bring back gear stats" and unhelpful hate posts to threads that are focused on that.


    Outside of the awful implementation from gear stats to perks.. which was awful, there is no denying that. The biggest thing that perks took away wasn't the bonuses but the point to grinding and improving gear. You can get your three perks at 162 gear or less, so whats the point of 180 and refining. This needs to be fixed. They also limited perk combos too the class instead of letting players choose how they want to play. My suggestion for improvement fixes both of these items and gives players the ability to experiment with different perk combos to find what works for them. My suggestion will also simplify the addition of future perks.


    Part 1: Get rid of RNG and class limited perks
    Perks are no longer attributes of gear, No more grinding forever to get the pieces that just happen to have the perks you want.
    All perks are available to all classes, no more limiting what perks a class can have


    Part 2: How to unlock a perk.
    We need to drop this "600 perk points" to unlock a perk and the unneeded complexity.
    Each gear point is worth 1 point. So total score of "Perk points" is 180. Fully refining all your gear gives you a max of 216 Perk Points. You can spend these points as you see fit to unlock the perks you want


    Common Perks: A, B, C perks cost 36 Points
    Rare Perks: D, E Perks cost 72 Points
    Epic Perks: F, G perks cost 108 Points.


    Part 3: Perk Combinations as you level your gear score
    Gear Score 36 gives 1 Common perk choice
    Gear Score 72 gives 1 Rare or 2 Common perks
    Gear Score 108 gives 1 Epic, or 1 Rare/1 Common, or 3 Common
    Gear Score 144 gives 1 Epic/1 Common or 2 Rare Or 1 Rare/2 Common
    Gear Score 180 gives 1 Epic/1 Rare or 2 Rare/1 Common or 3 Common
    Gear Score 216 gives 2 Epic or 1 Epic/1 Rare/1 Common or 3 Rare or 2 Rare/2 Common, or 1 Epic/3 Common.

    Perk 4: Experimentation
    It costs 1000 steel or 1000 salvage to reset your Perk points to be reused on any perks you want. This allows you to reset spent perk points to Zero and respend your gear score on new perk combinations to allow players to experiement with different perks.

    This method gives Players a reason to gear up and refine their gear.
    This method takes the RNG out of gear grinding
    This method means devs don't need to create a new perk for every class before releasing. They can create one new perk, pick its level (Common, rare, epic) and release it.
    This method also means if a new perk is release you dont need to RNG grind all your gear again to try and get the new perk, only to level up that gear again. The pointless grind is out, but still gives a reason to grind up to 180 refined.

    Constructive feedback is welcome.
    Please thumbs up this post if you would rather this to the current way perks are being used.
     16 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  2. #2
    +1 i like this
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  3. #3
    This is very well thought out.
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  4. #4
    So so good
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  5. #5
    Agree completely!
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  6. #6
    Thanks for the support. Spread the word on this thread, lets get the devs to notice that perks need a fix.
    So many people have given up on gear.
    Share this post

  7. #7
    Lovely system, and well laid out. Though I still prefer being able to just modify raw stats as it was originally. Hell, have gear stats and perks at the same time. I dont really care, I just want gear stats back. Perk system is very linear, dysfunctional and does not allow fine tuning a hero to your play style like gear stats did.

    Id like to see how this would work but I dont believe it will trump gear stats for that exact reason, You cannot fine tune your hero to your play style as well as gear stats.
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  8. #8
    Originally Posted by AmnElIthTirSol Go to original post
    Lovely system, and well laid out. Though I still prefer being able to just modify raw stats as it was originally. Hell, have gear stats and perks at the same time. I dont really care, I just want gear stats back. Perk system is very linear, dysfunctional and does not allow fine tuning a hero to your play style like gear stats did.

    Id like to see how this would work but I dont believe it will trump gear stats for that exact reason, You cannot fine tune your hero to your play style as well as gear stats.
    That is fair to say and I can understand that want for gear stats to return. I have thought about doing a post about gear stats coming back and how to level them out. However like I said in my OP this post was focused on accepting they were gone. I would rather have a functional system than no system at all which currently perks are broken. Poorly implemented design especially for the long term higher level fan.
    I would argue that you could fine tune your hero with perks more if they used my system update due to the large number of perks available to all classes and the ability for players to experiment with different builds as well as the devs would have an easier time adding more perks for more build combinations without having to release a new one for every class type, you could release a single perk and do this once a season if they wanted too. Something to change it up.
    Share this post

  9. #9
    Nice Idea! +1
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  10. #10
    So much more elegant than what we've got!
    Share this post

Page 1 of 4 123 ... Last ►►