Rep 54 Shinobi here , just throwing my two cents here “ no pun intended “. I have come to the conclusion that Shinobi needs a midrange tweak to his kit. As of now he can perform quite effectively at long range and close range. 2 or 3 moves added to his kit that help close the gap between long to mid and mid to close, in my “ opinion “ will balance him out. Of course his recovery time and overall defensive capabilities need a retweak as well. The tracking and speed on some of his heavies is way to slow for his class. Furthermore the moves that I suggest be implemented into his kit should be defensive offense. Meaning they won’t inflict damage, but will either stun , unbalance, or knockdown opponents. I also suggest a replacement zone attack. His old minions heavy attack. Make it have an unblockable propety and swing around 3 times. This will be most valuable in anti gank situations.