On foot action?? | Forums

[Y2A_Alkis]

nice propaganda right there those are just excuses and I dont think they have even tried it...I dont know if its laziness, greed or both....of course I'm not saying they should add the AC melee combat in multiplayer BUT they could make a different melee combat for the multiplayer to work...its just they not even trying dude

Stop. You're not even on topic anymore. You are beginning to slander the devs with your wild accusations because for some unknown reason you don't want to believe what Justin Farren said - probably because it fits your own narrative.

How can you possibly know what the dev team have tried and what they didn't? You have no freaking clue what they did so far. They have a clear vision of what they want the game to be. Period. If that's not your cup of tea, then get outta here, and go play a game that fits more of what you want to play. But stop spreading negativity and false information in this place of people who actually like the game the way it's going to be and like to be genuinely involved with constructive feedback. You are becoming a basic troll and nothing else.

On topic: It's already been stated multiple times (because you bring it up in basically every thread you post in) that melee combat is not going to be core gameplay of SnB.

[DeeK_KayE]

Stop. You're not even on topic anymore. You are beginning to slander the devs with your wild accusations because for some unknown reason you don't want to believe what Justin Farren said - probably because it fits your own narrative.

How can you possibly know what the dev team have tried and what they didn't? You have no freaking clue what they did so far. They have a clear vision of what they want the game to be. Period. If that's not your cup of tea, then get outta here, and go play a game that fits more of what you want to play. But stop spreading negativity and false information in this place of people who actually like the game the way it's going to be and like to be genuinely involved with constructive feedback. You are becoming a basic troll and nothing else.

On topic: It's already been stated multiple times (because you bring it up in basically every thread you post in) that melee combat is not going to be core gameplay of SnB.

and how do you know that the devs tried it? you know, melee combat doesnt have to be "core" gameplay of skull and bones but it SHOULD be in the game...its not a pirate game otherwise...just some boring naval action game...they dont understand the potential man

[drunktyrone]

ok lemme tell you why I and many other people think so: because an open world online pirate game should also have island/underwater explorations and sword and gun combat...not just naval combat...if you can only do naval combat in this game, then its gonna get very boring very fast....why not make something like black flag online where you can do everything of the pirate fantasy....in this game you can only do 1 part of the pirate fantasy which is the naval combat...naval stuff is good and all but if thats the only thing you can do in the game, well then.....not much of a nice online open world pirate game

I'm not going to call the game a flop. It could still be fun, but just in a different way than I had hoped... I'm with you on every other point. I was just hoping for a massive open world pirate game along the lines of GTA, or RDR(yes I know those had different developers), but the pirate genre would be so much fun to have a game like that. So much more you could do than just sailing a boat around the whole time.

[DeeK_KayE]

I'm not going to call the game a flop. It could still be fun, but just in a different way than I had hoped... I'm with you on every other point. I was just hoping for a massive open world pirate game along the lines of GTA, or RDR(yes I know those had different developers), but the pirate genre would be so much fun to have a game like that. So much more you could do than just sailing a boat around the whole time.

yeah exactly!

[Y2A_Alkis]

and how do you know that the devs tried it? you know, melee combat doesnt have to be "core" gameplay of skull and bones but it SHOULD be in the game...its not a pirate game otherwise...just some boring naval action game...they dont understand the potential man

1. I never claimed to know what the devs tried - you did by calling them "lazy", "greedy", and "they're not even trying".

2. "it's not a pirate game otherwise [without melee combat]" - Dead wrong. We provided proof that historical piracy had nothing to do with melee combat, yet you choose to ignore facts. "Piracy in modern popular culture" is what you want. But that's not what SnB is going to be.

3. Potential of what? Catering to a vocal minority who doesn't even like the game for what it is and wants something completely different? The devs have a clear vision of what they want SnB to be. And there will be engaged fans no matter what.

So please stop spreading false information. It's clear that SnB won't be a game for you, so please quit the trolling.

[DeeK_KayE]

1. I never claimed to know what the devs tried - you did by calling them "lazy", "greedy", and "they're not even trying".

2. "it's not a pirate game otherwise [without melee combat]" - Dead wrong. We provided proof that historical piracy had nothing to do with melee combat, yet you choose to ignore facts. "Piracy in modern popular culture" is what you want. But that's not what SnB is going to be.

3. Potential of what? Catering to a vocal minority who doesn't even like the game for what it is and wants something completely different? The devs have a clear vision of what they want SnB to be. And there will be engaged fans no matter what.

So please stop spreading false information. It's clear that SnB won't be a game for you, so please quit the trolling.

so you are telling me that pirates back then didnt have any sword and gun fights at all? haha hell no...thats wrong! its not even the minority, its actually the majority but if you dont believe it then fine, whatever..so like I said, they should just try it first

[Y2A_Alkis]

so you are telling me that pirates back then didnt have any sword and gun fights at all? haha hell no...thats wrong! its not even the minority, its actually the majority but if you dont believe it then fine, whatever..so like I said, they should just try it first

Not respongding to my laid-out points? Check.
Stating your opinion as fact? Check.
Not providing proof for statements after repeatedly asked for? Check.
Continuing to spread false information? Check.
Not doing anything to progress a good conversation? Check.

Yup, that's a troll. I won't try to have a real conversation with you anymore. Enjoy being blocked. Have a good day and I hope you find a game you'll actually like.

[DeeK_KayE]

Not respongding to my laid-out points? Check.
Stating your opinion as fact? Check.
Not providing proof for statements after repeatedly asked for? Check.
Continuing to spread false information? Check.
Not doing anything to progress a good conversation? Check.

Yup, that's a troll. I won't try to have a real conversation with you anymore. Enjoy being blocked. Have a good day and I hope you find a game you'll actually like.

I'm not a troll and I'm dead serious about this! and I dont spread false information, I spread the right information but you dont know about it since you are only active in the ubisoft forums...ever taken a look at the skull and bones videos on youtube and skull and bones threads on steam? I dont think so...I dont even need to prove it when you can just take a look at it yourself...and yes, pirates DID have melee combat back then so stop making excuses...thanks

[Ubi-Lucipus]

I understand that this topic is subject to a lot of heated debate so I'd like to remind you to keep it civilised

[FuryPrinceUBI]

I'm not a troll and I'm dead serious about this! and I dont spread false information, I spread the right information but you dont know about it since you are only active in the ubisoft forums...ever taken a look at the skull and bones videos on youtube and skull and bones threads on steam? I dont think so...I dont even need to prove it when you can just take a look at it yourself...and yes, pirates DID have melee combat back then so stop making excuses...thanks

Pirates also done a lot of different things, horrible ones, think they should be in too? I don't want to name them but I think you'll know what. And also, you keep saying that it'll be a good thing, why in the world - in a naval game; would sword fighting be good? I CaN dEsTrOy A wHoLe ShIp iF I JuMp oVeRbOaRd AnD pOkE sOmEOne WIth a sWorD eY?