1. #1

    All overpowered and underpowered cards IMO

    I initially wrote notes beside each card explaining why I rate them as I do, and what balance changes I believe they need - but I have since decided to remove the notes so as note to detract and distract from the list itself. Readers can interpret my reasons and imagine their own balances as they see fit.

    ADVENTURER
    Overpowered:
    FIREBALL
    STAN OF MANY MOONS
    HOOKHAND CLYDE
    SHAMAN TOKEN

    Underpowered:
    BUCCANEER BEBE
    OUTLAW TWEEK
    MEDICINE WOMAN SHARON
    INUIT KENNY



    SCIFI
    Overpowered:
    ALIEN QUEEN RED
    POISON
    ALIEN CLYDE
    ENFORCER JIMMY
    MECHA TIMMY
    ASTRONAUT BUTTERS

    Underpowered:
    AWESOM-O 4000
    ICE SNIPER WENDY
    PROGRAM STAN
    FREEZE RAY
    GIZMO IKE
    WARBOY TWEEK
    VISITORS



    MYSTICAL
    Overpowered:
    Nothing

    Underpowered:
    POPE TIMMY
    ENERGY STAFF
    MEDUSA BEBE
    THE MASTER NINJEW
    WITCH DOCTOR TOKEN
    CUPID CARTMAN
    HERMES KENNY
    CHOIRBOY BUTTERS
    POWERBIND
    PURIFY
    Also: Theme needs a 3-4 cost 'backrow unit' removal



    FANTASY:
    Overpowered:
    COOK MAGIC
    ROGUE TOKEN
    CANADIAN KNIGHT IKE
    STAN THE GREAT
    PRINCESS KENNY

    Underpowered:
    LE BARD JIMMY
    ROBIN TWEEK
    THE AMAZINGLY RANDY
    DARK MAGE CRAIG
    SHIELDMAIDEN WENDY
    Share this post

  2. #2
    The 2 most questionable appearances on this list are probably PROGRAM STAN and MEDUSA BEBE, so I'll explain those.

    PROGRAM STAN isn't bad per se, it's just that all other stans are currently better. IMO the freeze functionality needs a rework in general. Frozen units could receive x% more damage from attacks, for example.

    MEDUSA BEBE has a brilliant body for a ranged unit, but her damage output is underwhelming allowing units to easily close in on her and take her out.. Either boost her damage or give her another ability such as poisonous arrows or a chance to turn nearby enemies to stone.
    Share this post

  3. #3
    Correcting you:

    Adventure: none
    Theme is very nicely balanced.
    Stan of many moons is a lil stronger but easy to counter.

    Mystic: zen cartman, friar jimmy

    Fantasy: stan the great, PK, PB, rogue token.

    Scifi: mecha timmy, poison at high level.

    Underpowered:

    Inuit kenny
    Shieldmaiden wendy
    And a few others.

    Astro butters is horrible, how you think he is good... no idea...
    I play him and would trade him for pk or pb any day.
    His hitrate and deathwish are trash.
    Share this post

  4. #4
    Fireball needs smaller radius or cost 6.

    HH clyde and Alien clyde. Should cost 4.

    Red is OP as hell. Warcry needs to be slower so you can actually react to it. And. Maybe 10sec limit on her poison. Or increase cost.

    Poison should cost 4.

    Somm half warcry dmg

    Terrance lower hp by 25%

    Inuit kenny, just make him common so he can be leveled up to usable and cost 3.

    Mecha Timmy cost 5. Or change his power to freeze enemy.

    Awsomeo should cost 4

    Gw cartman should cost 5
    Share this post

  5. #5
    Originally Posted by Geerti95 Go to original post
    Correcting you:

    Adventure: none
    Theme is very nicely balanced.
    Really? Let's take a look at some cards.
    HOOKHAND CLYDE: a 3 cost unit with a warcry that can insta-kill a 4 cost unit, essentially making him a negative 1 cost fighter.
    SHAMAN TOKEN: a 3 cost unit with a board-wide, potentially 'multiple' PURIFY effect. PURIFY itself is 2 cost and tiny aoe. PURIFY got 1 to 2 energy nerf but TOKEN unchanged?

    BUCCANEER BEBE: a 4 cost unit with a similar (but worse) ability than 3 cost ROBO BEBE.
    OUTLAW TWEEK: a 4 cost unit with a similar (but worse) ability than 3 cost HOOKHAND CLYDE.
    MEDICINE WOMAN SHARON: a 4 cost unit with a similar (but worse) ability than 3 cost ANGEL WENDY.

    You only have to compare OUTLAW TWEEK and HOOKHAND CLYDE to see AVENTURER isn't even balanced with itself, let alone other themes.
    Share this post

  6. #6
    What rank do you guys play...

    If you think AQR is OP...

    Purify is 2 cost and shaman is 3 cost.

    Because you seem pretty new i will tell you why they not op.

    Hookhand often misses and can be countered by a swarm or tank.

    Buccaneer bebe at level 5
    400hp 90 attack
    30 attack increase per hit..
    Can you imagine the carnage?
    Shes veeery dangerous and a snowball if you dont take her out in time.

    Shaman token does not heal mind control only poison and other effects.
    Shaman takes 13 seconds to charge by the time his charge is ready poison has killed him so no he needs skill to be played.

    High level sharon heals 100+ with a very fast skill animation.
    She now also heals your newkid making it possible to fully heal your newkid easily.

    Oh and outlaw is multiple targets and he always hits units unlike hookhand... ontop of that he could kill rats and is therefore harder to counter.
    Share this post

  7. #7
    I sit around 1200 legendary, I've played enough to get a sense of what is OP.

    Yes purify is 2 vs 3 shaman, but shaman purifies the entire board whereas the actual purify aoe is so small I've seen units walk out of it before it casts on them. Not to mention shaman can do it multiple times while he is alive. Even if he gets off just one, that already makes him a 1 cost fighter.

    AQR is OP because she is SCIFI's board wipe.
    COOK MAGIC is OP because it's FANTASY's board wipe.
    STAN OF MANY MOONS is OP because it's ADVENTURER's board wipe.
    MYSTICAL does not have a board wipe - partly why it is suffering in comparison. I'm not saying it should have one, rather all other themes should not.
    Share this post

  8. #8
    By the way SHAMAN TOKEN should heal mind control, just as he should not remove mind control from himself when used by the enemy - this is lazy coding, not intentional.
    Share this post

  9. #9
    Aqr and cockmagic are not boardwipes.
    They are punishment of overplaying.
    Aqr cannot stop a push when its a paladin ike combo.
    Aqr only stops idiots who put zen friar angel behind their newkid like an idiot.

    Rogue is boardwipe.
    Fireball is boardwipe.
    Oh and stan of many moons is not that dangerous.

    Mystic has a regen that heals 32 over an entire board.
    A tank with twice the health of sherif and a lower cost that can attract headhunters.
    Friar jimmy who has sick stats and ontop of that heals everyone by 8 or 10 at high level and purify to shut down any attempt to poison.

    So aqr is not a boardwipe.. not against mystic. Purify wich shuts down aqr and gives you 3 energy advantage...

    Please stop saying ridiculous thing.

    Mystic is still just as OP its just a very boring theme...
    Share this post

  10. #10
    No shaman token removes all negative effects from allies...

    If hes mindcontrolled thats a negative effect... on an ally... so he will heal himself.

    Why does he not heal mindcontrol:
    Those are not allies.

    The coding is indeed done right.
    Just not what you expected.
    Share this post

Page 1 of 4 123 ... Last ►►