[Spoiler Alert] Earlier today I was playing and did John’s showdown where he summons you to the church, and I chased and killed him afterwards in order to get his key. I got off after that mission but now that I logged back in, it says I’m still in the Showdown with him. But then in the journal it tells me that I’ve beaten The Atonement and Wrath, which are the actual missions within the Shodown.
Does anybody know how I should go about fixing this?