Unfortunately if this didn't work, and subsequently turning on the Saves again shows the same, then unfortunately it's likely that the save is not retrievable.
As such you will likely need to continue from this earlier save.
I have the same issue but in my case it's much serious. I had a 72 hours character level 40 with all epic items and 99 completion and after patch 1.2.0 I only have a level 18 save. I have also tried to disable cloud sync but with no success.
Any suggestions?