If I understand you right, then I believe what you saw was an overall reputation of that player's account. Maybe the latest update went past you and you were unaware of the fact that now you see a total reputation in the loading screen instead of a singular, per-hero reputation, thus you can see players of reputation 117, 87 or 61 etc. You can swap between this, new overview and the old one by pressing Ctrl.
Now, if that wasn't what you had on your mind, then the highest reputation one can have PER HERO (character), is 30. It's displayed in the smaller circle. Therefore I believe that the number you saw was a total reputation accumulated from all the other heroes. I believe everything is correct and fair.![]()
In 1.09 we changed the face-off screen so the new number you're seeing is the sum of all the rep across all heroes. Patch notes here.