For all the players who are complaining about a quitting penalty. | Forums

[Supercool5150]

Shut up noob! You suck at this game!!!

Such anger Antonio...To be honest I really do hate rage quitters. However you did ask wouldn't the game be better if connection issues were better. I simply answered yes.

[Antonioj26]

Such anger Antonio...To be honest I really do hate rage quitters. However you did ask wouldn't the game be better if connection issues were better. I simply answered yes.

I do too, who the hell likes rage quitters? I'm against the penalty right now but if they ever get the game working I'm all for it. I bet more than half the people who are against it are just against it right now, not indefinitely.

[Supercool5150]

I do too, who the hell likes rage quitters? I'm against the penalty right now but if they ever get the game working I'm all for it. I bet more than half the people who are against it are just against it right now, not indefinitely.

I totally agree with everything you said. For example, am I going to be penalized when the session owner leaves and then the session owner migration freezes the game and my only choice is to quit? That is really going to piss me off if that happens.

[K1os1Xos]

I don't condone or disagree with the implimentation of a bad sport penalty. I just would prefer if it was at least fair to all involved.

So will dashboarding on Xbox be seen as a DC or quitting?... And will that be punishable? I'm not quite sure the system will be able to differentiate between dashboarding, rage quitting, error Dcing or anything else. I believe most games don't. Elite dangerous doesn't and one of their biggest issues is combat loggers. Halo ranked doesn't. CoD doesn't. Those are just a few games that have "bad sport" penalties. DC's and logging is seen as the same because that's how their servers see it. Just depends on when it happens.

If I'm wrong however and their system can see the difference between all the types of connection loss then... Props to Ubi.

But those games also don't deal with the entire game crashing when one person leaves. AND penalties are usually not distributed on the first offense. Hmm.

A thought also occurred that instead of having a "ragequitpenalty" Ubi could just remove the "quit" option from the pause menu. That would have removed the issue of people "quitting" in the middle of a game because they'd no longer have the option... But more people would dashboard or quick close. So who knows... Which again begs the question... How will different types of DC be treated?


Just funny people will be punished for using a feature which every game, to my knowledge, mostly impliment. Punished for using a feature as intended.

Oh well. Won't know till it happens. I don't expect much difference.

[K1os1Xos]

Can't edit above post. In warriors den today. Apparently, based on the post, the penalty system will be able to tell between different types of disconnections. That's cool... Don't completely believe it. But hey.

Like I said above. Will have to wait and see.

[rossato2109]

I don't condone or disagree with the implimentation of a bad sport penalty. I just would prefer if it was at least fair to all involved.

So will dashboarding on Xbox be seen as a DC or quitting?... And will that be punishable? I'm not quite sure the system will be able to differentiate between dashboarding, rage quitting, error Dcing or anything else. I believe most games don't. Elite dangerous doesn't and one of their biggest issues is combat loggers. Halo ranked doesn't. CoD doesn't. Those are just a few games that have "bad sport" penalties. DC's and logging is seen as the same because that's how their servers see it. Just depends on when it happens.

If I'm wrong however and their system can see the difference between all the types of connection loss then... Props to Ubi.

But those games also don't deal with the entire game crashing when one person leaves. AND penalties are usually not distributed on the first offense. Hmm.

A thought also occurred that instead of having a "ragequitpenalty" Ubi could just remove the "quit" option from the pause menu. That would have removed the issue of people "quitting" in the middle of a game because they'd no longer have the option... But more people would dashboard or quick close. So who knows... Which again begs the question... How will different types of DC be treated?


Just funny people will be punished for using a feature which every game, to my knowledge, mostly impliment. Punished for using a feature as intended.

Oh well. Won't know till it happens. I don't expect much difference.

Dashboarding? I don't follow it, you can get dced in the xbox one for using the dashboard to send messages?

[SetMySail4Fail]

I pity those who really believe that punishing qutting players will actually do more good than harm. You are going to lose more and more players because the developers focus on superficialities instead of the fundamental issues this game has.

Just wait 2-3 months until the "Where did all the players go?", "Only premades left?!", "OMG UNFAIR MATCHMAKING =!)")!!111" and "How to get players back?" threads pop up.

[Antonioj26]

I pity those who really believe that punishing qutting players will actually do more good than harm. You are going to lose more and more players because the developers focus on superficialities instead of the fundamental issues this game has.

Just wait 2-3 months until the "Where did all the players go?", "Only premades left?!", "OMG UNFAIR MATCHMAKING =!)")!!111" and "How to get players back?" threads pop up.

It really is unfortunate that all of their anger is misplaced on the players that quit instead of Ubisoft for putting out a half finished product.

[K1os1Xos]

Dashboarding? I don't follow it, you can get dced in the xbox one for using the dashboard to send messages?

On Xbox one... Maybe it was back on 360. People would dashboard and use it to manually quit the game, bypassing in game systems(or dashboarding exited the game on its own... I don't recall.). I don't use PC and my PS4 gathers dust so IDK what to compare it to... Not as pertinent now... But dashboarding and then quitting using xbox has the same effect. It doesn't send any info to the games servers. To a lot of games it looks like a server timeout to the devs.

Also a question. Will idle timeout be seen as a voluntary quit and result in punishment?

[DrExtrem]

The manual logout?
This should still be possible. Double tab the xbox button and then sign out via the guide.

If no player is selected, the game should disconnect your client.