🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The For Honor forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game
  1. #1

    Exhaustion needs stronger penalties.

    Title, it needs to be more punishable. Especially towards PKs/Orochis that can double backdash and play it out (orochi not as good as PK dodge but still very noticable)

    You should not be able to use ANY dodge move, PERIOD. After exhaustion. You can parry, but it shouldn't inflict stamina damage. You can block, but you should take extra damage for blocking. You can CGB but you cannot GB.

    Match after match, I see pks who spam, then double dodge out reset and its pretty impossible to catch them because of speed of the dodge, and distance it gives, you can't even catch them if you unlock and try to run up and GB most of time because of how much speed/distance it gives. Especially on slower character like kensai.

    Some might disagree with it so they can keep up bs tactics like this but I firmly believe DODGING needs a stamina cost, blocking needs one (only for blocking heavies, otherwise making it cost stamina to block lights would indirectly buff PKs who force everyone defense). And crippling exhaustion penalties.

    While were at it, buff block damage lol, I have it maxed on my kensai and when people choose to block over parry (rare but it happens) man it really does nothing, even from a heavy.
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  2. #2
    I disagree since it would make defensive game even stronger.
    Playing offensive requires to use stamina, turteling does not. Besides, the way the game works right now makes it even worse because attacking in a shield actually drains stamina, which mean you can get out of stamina in a pinch just because you tried to open your opponent';s guard.

    If you prevent peoples out of stamina to dodge, players will not even take the risk to parry, they will wait for you to attack, depletes your stamina and when you're out (keep in mind, Warlord, Valkyrie, Conqueror...they have moves that drains stamina) they just have to pick you up and kill you.

    Not to mention the Shugoki and Lawbringer who will fall to oblivion...
     2 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  3. #3
    Gray360UK's Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2015
    Posts
    2,800
    I disagree too. Play as Shoguki for a bit. You think he is slow before he gets exhausted ....
    Share this post

  4. #4
    Make dodging and blocking require stamina when not exhausted.

    This will help destroy the defense meta.

    This will help exhaustion be more prevalent. If an assassin is exhausted you need to sprint at them and attack if you can't move fast enough. PK can't double back when exhausted, she has to do them one at a time. You can run faster, but if you're a Warden or another slow dodger you need to unlock.
    Share this post

  5. #5
    Munktor's Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    1,065
    Another perfect example of a person trying to "fix" a problem from their personal perspective instead of thinking about the entire game and all the mechanics.

    Other people have already pointed out why you "solution" would do more harm to the game than good.
    Share this post

  6. #6
    Dodging/blocking should not cost stamina, especially when exhausted; that would cause an unsurvivable snowball effect. My best idea is for dodging speed/distance to be reduced, and *maybe* disable rolling. The entire reason why assassins are nigh impossible to catch if they are played well is because exhaustion does nothing to impact their evasiveness. That, has to change.
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  7. #7
    TCTF_SWAT's Avatar Senior Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2016
    Location
    UltraTech HQ
    Posts
    858
    Originally Posted by Stop_Poking_Me Go to original post
    Title, it needs to be more punishable. Especially towards PKs/Orochis that can double backdash and play it out (orochi not as good as PK dodge but still very noticable)

    You should not be able to use ANY dodge move, PERIOD. After exhaustion. You can parry, but it shouldn't inflict stamina damage. You can block, but you should take extra damage for blocking. You can CGB but you cannot GB.

    Match after match, I see pks who spam, then double dodge out reset and its pretty impossible to catch them because of speed of the dodge, and distance it gives, you can't even catch them if you unlock and try to run up and GB most of time because of how much speed/distance it gives. Especially on slower character like kensai.

    Some might disagree with it so they can keep up bs tactics like this but I firmly believe DODGING needs a stamina cost, blocking needs one (only for blocking heavies, otherwise making it cost stamina to block lights would indirectly buff PKs who force everyone defense). And crippling exhaustion penalties.

    While were at it, buff block damage lol, I have it maxed on my kensai and when people choose to block over parry (rare but it happens) man it really does nothing, even from a heavy.
    I like the way he thinks. Please, make it happen. I want to be a master pancake flipper.

    Why aren't you in the gaming business with these ideas? Seriously, you'd make a killing off it.
    Share this post

  8. #8
    I see the various points here, but it wouldn't be hard to reduce stamina punishing abilities across board, and have exhaustion mechanic end automatically after incurring X amount of damage. It already doesn't last long. Heros shouldn't be able to easily punish you there with parries ontop of the parry punishment gb + dmg you took, and combine that with stamina sapping abilities. I think a few in the game exist around now that are completly excessive. Shugo headbutt and valk one for sure. Exhaustion is only a long forever window when you run max revenge duration + debuff ressist and have zero exhaustion recovery.

    Either way there needs to be some incentive to capitalize on someone exhausted. Not that they continue to turtle and counter GB and dodge while picking their noses,the green bar and exhaustion bar might as well not exist.
    Share this post

  9. #9
    Originally Posted by Kharneth88 Go to original post
    Make dodging and blocking require stamina when not exhausted.

    This will help destroy the defense meta.
    I think there is other way to nerf defensive game without affecting offensive one.
    Share this post

  10. #10

    imo

    exhausted assasins shouldnt be able to counterbreak GB.. that's would be my idea, or at least, or dash distance should be halved, or dash cd should be doubled, that would force them at least to take care about stamina.
    Share this post