🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The For Honor forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game

View Poll Results: Counter Guard Break Window

Voters
83. You may not vote on this poll
  • The window is just fine.

    30 36.14%
  • The window needs to be widened.

    39 46.99%
  • The window is impeding me from retaking the Holy Land!

    14 16.87%
  1. #11
    Well can I just ask for help? Im just doing the story mode and this ragnar guy has been killing me for the past hour. All he can do is guardbreak me and run me into a wall. I have no clue how to defend it and its frustrating as hell.

    So yes noob, yes asking for help, yes attempting to git gud, so plz help.
    Share this post

  2. #12
    Originally Posted by Redscyte Go to original post
    Well can I just ask for help? Im just doing the story mode and this ragnar guy has been killing me for the past hour. All he can do is guardbreak me and run me into a wall. I have no clue how to defend it and its frustrating as hell.

    So yes noob, yes asking for help, yes attempting to git gud, so plz help.
    Either you guardreak yourself when you see the symbol that he is doing which requires some practise to react fast enough and to get the right timing but is possible. Or you attack him when you think he will do this because he can't guardbreak you when you are about to hit him.
    Share this post

  3. #13
    The problem is not the counter window. In fact countering a GB is just as easy as it has been. The window seems to be as soon as the character actually touches you. But the problem is that if you press the GB button at any time after your opponent presses GB, but before the designated counter window, you automatically fail the counter. Even if you were going for a GB yourself and your opponent just happened to hit the button a slight fraction of a second before you did then your "GB attempt" actually registers as a failed GB counter and you automatically fail the counter attempt. This so broken it's ridiculous. Now GB is a complete 50/50 gamble that awards a heavy punish to the winner of the 50/50 guessing game of chicken.

    It's especially bad in 1vX situations and GB spam will be an even greater cancer than what people considered it to be now. Constantly automatically failing GB's when you yourself were going for the GB and then getting tossed into hazards is incredibly frustrating as you have little to no control over it especially in outnumbered situations as it's incredibly difficult to notice this window when an external attacker is trying to GB you.

    Not to mention how varying connection speeds will have an even greater impact on this as opposed to how it was before. Before you could at least anticipate a GB in addition to your own reactions as you could hit the button as soon as you saw the GB animation start and get a counter.

    The window needs to be strictly at the beginning of the character GB animation and made tighter. This way even in varying connection speeds you can anticipate the GB along with quick reactions to successfully counter a GB. All the while countering GB's becomes a little more difficult making GB's more effective in higher lvl play as well. The way it is now is just awful for all levels of play.

    You might think it could be ok in 1v1, which it almost is. But Like I said if you and your opponent try to GB at more or less the same time, then whoever happened to hit GB slightly sooner will get the GB and your attempt becomes a failed GB counter giving no more chance to counter the GB. So as I said GB is a complete gamble now it's ridiculous. Imagine an assassin vs say a warlord. A warlord can chunk roughly 35% of an assassins health with one heavy off GB. Whereas the assassin does much less dmaage to the warlord, so his risk for attempting a GB is MUCH higher than that of the warlord so why would he ever want to risk a GB atte,pt when that attempt could very easily through no fault of his own turn into a free GB+heavy on himself that will do much more dmaage than he would have done had he been successful.
     4 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  4. #14

    agree

    Responding to show my agreement. I played in CB and OB and was able to counter guard breaks regularly, if i was anticipating it. Now since launch I cannot counter any, and have spend the last 30 minutes in a lvl 3 bot duel to try and relearn the timings.. its still not apparent and is getting quite frustrating.
     3 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  5. #15
    Could it also be a network problem. Cause since open beta, I also offten get interupted by GB, even I already startet an Attack, wich should't be able to be interupted by GB. never had this problems in earlyer Tests.

    And not just me, I also sometimes interupt others in there attack with a GB, tahts Why I thoght tahts a general Problem since open Beta.
     2 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  6. #16

    I agree, should be fixed

    I was apart of the alpha, closed beta, and beta and never had any issues with this. Now since the game came out I cant block any. So these new people who don't know how to do combos exploiting this like crazy. In a game where spamming a move shouldn't help, it seems that spamming guard break wins fights. Please look into this.
     3 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  7. #17
    Originally Posted by CaptainPwnet Go to original post
    The problem is not the counter window. In fact countering a GB is just as easy as it has been. The window seems to be as soon as the character actually touches you. But the problem is that if you press the GB button at any time after your opponent presses GB, but before the designated counter window, you automatically fail the counter. Even if you were going for a GB yourself and your opponent just happened to hit the button a slight fraction of a second before you did then your "GB attempt" actually registers as a failed GB counter and you automatically fail the counter attempt. This so broken it's ridiculous. Now GB is a complete 50/50 gamble that awards a heavy punish to the winner of the 50/50 guessing game of chicken.

    A thousand times this. There needs to be an additional window at the start where if both people use it within ~50 ms of each other they counter each other instead of just awarding one of them a 100% uncounterable GB. The current implementation is bad, and whoever decided on it should feel bad.
    Share this post

  8. #18
    Enxyne's Avatar Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2017
    Posts
    11

    agreed

    I don't understand why sometimes I'm in the animation to guard break and it still doesn't connect. I'm not liking the windows very much, either. It's not clear as to when you're counterable or when you are able to counter them.
    Share this post

  9. #19
    Originally Posted by hafeatnburito Go to original post
    All I got from that was "Guys, Im so f****** gud at this game that FaZe already asked me to join there team as team captain. Im just that next level! Everybody else is just a bunch of plebian scum lords compared to how exceedingly awesome I am. If any scrubs think they can 1v1 me, my screen name is XXN0sc0pesxx420XXswagl0rdXXdudeManBroxX." lol get off your high-horse
    Basically but let us face the simple fact that proves it needs a fix. GB spams.
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  10. #20
    Its fine. If you cant handle it you should improve. Not even 24h after release complaining about THIS is sad.
    Share this post