🛈 Announcement
Greetings! The For Honor forums are now archived and accessible in read-only mode, please go to the new platform to discuss the game
  1. #1

    Please Revert Deflecting (sort of)

    Okay, so before anyone decides to just read the title and leave an angry comment: I'm not asking for Deflections to be fully reverted to Alpha levels.

    So hear me out. I've played this game almost nonstop since the Beta dropped and I kept my ear to the ground during the Alpha just so I could keep myself in the loop. The Orochi's deflection in Alpha was absolutely ludicrous, so I understand the need to nerf the window and the fact that they're testing the waters in terms of remapping the ability into a dodge rather than a block.

    However, in my opinion, they need to remap the Deflect back to the right stick. The maneuver was clearly intended for stationary characters, so often as the peacekeeper I find myself dodging into an attack (due to poor timing on my own part) or being struck by attacks which I thought were timed properly. The window is often rather inconsistent, perhaps due to the inherent P2P lag. There is simply no reason to deflect rather than parry at this point. The parry is simply a superior move with a much, much better balance of risk-reward. Compare this to the dodge-based deflection, which if mistimed can cost you upwards of 75% of your health. And what do you get for your troubles? A counterattack which can combo into, what, 25% health on some of the lighter characters?

    Now I'm no fool. I've seen the videos. I know how that stuff used to be. I'm not asking to widen the window or anything which will re-break the assassins back into Alpha Orochi territory. But I simply can't justify deflecting in the current build of the game when parrying is a much better decision on every front. Yeah there's a lot about this game that I still need to learn. Yeah I'm still working on my timing for a lot of stuff. But while I can chalk up getting overwhelming by attack barrages to needing to learn my options better, I simply cannot overlook how useless the deflect maneuver is currently.

    I'm looking for some input here. Am I totally off my rocker in suggesting that this be remapped to RS? If anyone's got any pointers for how to reliably make these come out that I'm more than receptive. I just can't see these being anywhere near useful enough to risk eating a hit when I can just parry and follow up with an LA string (into dagger madness, because I personally play Peacekeeper)
     1 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  2. #2
    I totally agree with you. I went into a custom game duel with a level one bot warden, guess how many times I deflected, even with perfect timing? ZERO! it's absurd!
    Share this post

  3. #3
    Originally Posted by kID_is_onLINE Go to original post
    I totally agree with you. I went into a custom game duel with a level one bot warden, guess how many times I deflected, even with perfect timing? ZERO! it's absurd!
    Are you serious?
    Share this post

  4. #4
    I think if the problem were as simple as timing then I wouldn't be making this thread.

    The deflect being tied to something which commits you wholeheartedly in a direction, and an action which requires that you take your thumb off the ever-important joystick absolutely kills the risk-reward for deflections. I play on PS4, so obviously PC players aren't going to have this particular problem (though as I understand it you guys have an entirely different set of control problems).

    I understand the idea that deflecting is now more of a risk thanks to having to commit to it rather than simply flick it and probably still get a block even if you don't deflect. But to me it just very clearly WASN'T intended to be that way, and was nerfed a little bit too hard as a reaction to problems with the Orochi. This is, of course, despite the fact that (imo) the one of biggest problems for Orochi (Peacekeepers) wasn't in the Alpha iirc.

    I could also air out my many, many, many complaints with Dominion mode in this thread since I'm fresh off of a ridiculously salty loss streak thanks to P2P lag and team mates slapping me in the spine while I'm trying to stab people. But I think we'll save that for another day
    Share this post

  5. #5
    With the pool of players we have now, parry > deflect for reasons OP stated. However post-launch I feel everything will balance out and here is why.

    Parry reward > deflect reward. Deflect risk > parry risk. However the counter to parry is feint (which basically nobody is using since they have less than 24h experience). If a player begins feinting against a parry user, suddenly deflect risk < parry risk. Imagine whiffing a heavy because the attacker feinted. They're going to attack from a different direction and get a hit. Imagine whiffing a deflect (dodge) because the attacker feinted. Much lower risk since you're dodging, and on assassins you can even attack mid dodge when you notice the whiff.

    If deflect was made "too easy" with nearly zero risk, game play slows down and becomes too defensive. I believe this is why deflect was changed.
    Share this post

  6. #6
    i've tested this stuff a LOT too the last few days and i have to agree with OP... either deflect needs to work differently or the opportunity window needs to be a TINY bit bigger.

    against AI, deflects can be done with a consistency of at least 80% or more, but against humans, it feels almost impossible (even if the connection seems to be green and stable from both players.

    also, the deflect reward is laughably small... i can chain attack-combos together that take 50%+ of an enemies health without deflecting, but a deflect counter itself only does about the same damage as a light attack (or in orochis case his heavy counter equals about a heavy attack), basically it gives you a light or heavy hit (the heavy one not even being guaranteed to land) and interrupts the enemies combo (unless you are stupid enough to use the orochi's heavy deflect against someone midcombo, then youre counter will take too long before they hit you again).

    the window is so damn small, that the benefit of deflecting is soooo small, that a parry will always be the safer way, or just use dodges in general and chain them into side-step-attacks.

    i have also only encountered a SINGLE player during the whole weekend that actually used faint (which probably will change when ppl play more) but against those players deflecting becomes even more useless, as you need to react to the feint AND time the deflect, which just isnt going to happen consistently (esp not with the slightes lag)
    Share this post

  7. #7
    Cast_1's Avatar Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2017
    Didnt play the alpha, so I cannot comment on that. That said thouh. I absolutly loved deflect, i played the crap outta the peacekeeper, and with deflect i just murderer all other assasins, they never ever hit me. And the ultra fast light bleed attack you get after made it way to easy. Maybe your used to a different deflect? But i did not find it in any way hard to perform.
    Share this post

  8. #8
    after doing some more thinking and reading i think i might have a clue why it felt so inconsistent, but beta is over, so testing will have to wait for 2 weeks
    Share this post

  9. #9
    Deflect isn't necessarily more risky than parry. If you finding you're dodging into attacks, that's because your deflect is too late. When you're going for deflects, error on the side of dodging early. An early dodge will almost always still get you a dodge, and if you get the timing, you'll get the deflect. Late = you get hit. Parry is basically the opposite, it seems. A late parry = you probably still get the block. Early = you get hit.
     2 people found this helpful
    Share this post

  10. #10
    ^Exactly! That's what I came here to post. When I realised this I loved the change.
    Share this post