I basically judge Gaming Headsets by the predefined Standards which are also very well taken care by the manufacturers while designing the Headsets for gaming -
1) Design Comfort: I don't prefer bulky designs which becomes the barrier to my gaming experience. I personally hate those stuff. I try to give it a little bend to see the durability. I recently switch to the earbuds for gaming <-- All find the best buy here | rather than go for the bulky designs.
2) Sound: You will see a lot of people saying - "Why buying a pair of Gaming Headsets for better sound quality. I personally have one answer for them, Ask a Gamer and you will know, especially play those humming sounds of car crashing and Guns firing. Oh Bwoy! I am hungry
3) Studio Quality Sound: These arent necessarily be there, but that doesnt mean it should sound like all-bass-all-the-time. You know what I mean Right?
The Last but not the least - PRICE, The best all-around option is a bargain at $80,
Turtle Beach 600X Gen 2 + Dolby Atmos for headphones codec. (use Equalizer on the app to fine tune. For example raise 2 and 4 kHz a bit might help)
https://www.turtlebeach.com/products...gen-2-xbox-one