PDA

View Full Version : RANK THE MAIN AC GAMES:2015 EDITION!(link in description)

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 12:28 PM
RESULTS

1st:ACIV with a WR* of 2.61
2nd:ACII with a WR of 3.56
3rd:ACB with a WR of 4.54
4th:ACIII with a WR of 5.22
5th:ACR with a WR of 5.29
6th:ACU with a WR of 5.43
7th:AC with a WR of 5.44
8th:ACRo with a WR of 6.39
9th:ACIVFC with a WR of 7.32
10th:ACL with a WR of 8.68
(*WR stands for "weighted rank".I hadn't heard of that before,but it is used by Polldaddy.It is calculated as : (sum of (position*count) for each choice/total responses)+1.Something like an average position)

Some interesting facts:
-While ACIV was crowned victorious,it is tied with ACII regarding the most 1# places,as there is a 32,1% of people who believe that each of them is the best,respectively.Third in tha category lies ACU with 17,9%,with fourth having around 7%.
-The reason why ACIV won is that another 32,1% believes it is the second beat AC,while only a 10,7% believes that AC2 is he second best.Second in that category is ACR with 14,3%
-An amazing 32,1% believes that ACB is the third best AC.
-Finally,almost a 40% of people believs that ACL is the worst game.Second in that category is ACU with a 21,4%,while third is ACIII with 17,9%

Thank you for participating!

Fatal-Feit
01-07-2015, 12:45 PM
Opinion from best to worse:

IV, RO, FC, 3, R, U, 1, B, 2, L

Bias:

U, 3, IV, RO, FC, R, 1, B, 2, L

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 01:18 PM
Opinion from best to worse:

IV, RO, FC, 3, R, U, 1, B, 2, L

Bias:

U, 3, IV, RO, FC, R, 1, B, 2, L
What's the difference between the two?

Fatal-Feit
01-07-2015, 01:32 PM
The first one is my honest opinion on how the games stacks up against each other. The second one is what I personally prefer and enjoy.

Did the survey with the first one, btw.

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 05:10 PM
There are a few surprises,but not many people have voted yet.Come on lads!

Assassin_M
01-07-2015, 05:10 PM
This changes all the time for me.

1. AC IV
2. AC U/ AC I/ AC III
3. ACB/ ACR
4. ACL
5. AC II

SpiritOfNevaeh
01-07-2015, 05:17 PM
Always changes for me too, and I haven't played Rogue or Unity yet so :p

1. AC3/AC1
2. AC2/ACB
3. ACBF
4. ACL
5. ACR

m4r-k7
01-07-2015, 05:17 PM
Main console games:

AC 2 / AC 4
AC 1
AC 3 / AC U
AC B
AC R

Haven't played Rogue yet.

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 05:26 PM
Main console games:

AC 2 / AC 4
AC 1
AC 3 / AC U
AC B
AC R

Haven't played Rogue yet.

Always changes for me too, and I haven't played Rogue or Unity yet so :p

1. AC3/AC1
2. AC2/ACB
3. ACBF
4. ACL
5. ACR
It seems that neither of you have voted in the link.That't the point people.(if you haven't played some games rank them in the middle,i guess)

SixKeys
01-07-2015, 05:40 PM
I haven't played Rogue, so I don't know where I would place it. Can't be worse than AC3 though.

1. ACU
2. ACB
3. AC1
4. AC2
5. AC4
6. ACR
7. Freedom Cry
8. Liberation
9. AC3

Namikaze_17
01-07-2015, 05:40 PM
It changes for me sometimes...

1) AC1/AC3/AC4 ( Story-wise)
2) ACR/ ACRO
3) AC2/ACU
4) ACB/ACL

SpiritOfNevaeh
01-07-2015, 05:49 PM
It seems that neither of you have voted in the link.That't the point people.(if you haven't played some games rank them in the middle,i guess)

Done :)

GunnerGalactico
01-07-2015, 05:58 PM
It is also a fluctuating thing for me. Everything is still pretty much the same, except Rogue has now taken 4th place for me.

1. AC4
2. AC3
3. ACB
4. ACRo.
5. AC1
6. AC2
7. ACRe.
8. AC3L

* It might change after I complete Unity.

Shahkulu101
01-07-2015, 05:58 PM
ACIV/ACB
AC2
ACR
ACU
AC3/Rogue
AC1

Struggle to rank them to be honest, all I know is IV and Brotherhood are my absolute favorites. The rest of the rankings don't mean much, apart from AC1's last place.

ben-shawsy
01-07-2015, 06:19 PM
Haven't played Rogue yet, but it's hopefully arriving tomorrow so...

From best to worst:

II
Black Flag
Unity
Original
Brotherhood
III
Revelations

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 06:38 PM
Just to remind everyone to vote in the poll(link in description) so that i can collect the votes.Also,i suggest you rank the games you haven't placed so far in the middle(for example,if you haven't played two games,rank them 5th and 6th)
Some info until now:The last place is pretty much guaranteed.There is a great fight for the 3rd place,while the gap between the 1st and the second one is respectable,but not big.Keep voting!

JustPlainQuirky
01-07-2015, 06:47 PM
I have them in two categories. In terms of narrative and in terms of gameplay.

narrative:
1.) AC3
2.) ACRo
3.) AC2
4.) ACIV
5.) AC1
6.) ACRev
7.) ACFC
8.) ACU
9.)ACL
10.)ACB

in terms of gameplay

1.) ACIV
2.) ACU
3.) ACRo
4.) AC3
5.) AC2
The rest equal with exception of AC1 which is dead last

Pandassin
01-07-2015, 07:17 PM
From best to worse:

1. AC4
2. ACU
3. AC3
4. ACRo
5. ACFC
6. AC2

I haven't played any of the other games.

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 07:45 PM
From best to worse:

1. AC4
2. ACU
3. AC3
4. ACRo
5. ACFC
6. AC2

I haven't played any of the other games.

I am not quite sure you voted.May be wrong though.

rrebe
01-07-2015, 07:53 PM
AC4, ACU, AC3, AC1, ACRe, AC2, ACB, ACL

It's not a strict order, and I haven't played Rogue yet.

aL_____eX
01-07-2015, 08:00 PM
I hate ranking the games but here's my list...

ACIV
ACIII/AC:B
AC:R/ACII
ACU/ACL

Not gonna rate AC1 because it was a different game imo.

And I haven't finished Rogue yet but I guess it will be on one level with ACIII/ACB

To be honest they're all so close. ACL is last in my list, I still loved Aveline's story and the whole First Civ stuff in it. And Unity for example had the most improved gameplay of all, I just didn't like the narrative in it. Hmm... I think there's no real ranking for me. Every game has its pros and cons.

Pandassin
01-07-2015, 08:02 PM
I am not quite sure you voted.May be wrong though.

I haven't played all of the games you listed, so I couldn't really rank them.

dimbismp
01-07-2015, 10:46 PM
We have a relatively small,but respectable amount of votes.Still,it is really close and every vote counts,especially in 3-6 positions.
I'll wait until we have 1,5-2 times the current amount of votes to publish the results.The people who haven't registered heir vote yet should visit the link.(The main reason of this post is to bump thread :D )

The_Kiwi_
01-07-2015, 11:06 PM
Done.

king-hailz
01-07-2015, 11:24 PM
It always changes but these are the basics...

1. Assassin's Creed 2
2. Assassin's Creed Revelations
3. Assassin's Creed 4
4. Assassin's Creed 1
5. Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
(This is where Tyranny of King Washington would go)
6. Assassin's Creed Rogue
7. Assassin's Creed 3
8. Assassin's Creed Freedom Cry
9. Assassin's Creed Unity
10. Assassin's Creed Liberations

dimbismp
01-08-2015, 10:18 AM
RESULTS

1st:ACIV with a WR* of 2.61
2nd:ACII with a WR of 3.56
3rd:ACB with a WR of 4.54
4th:ACIII with a WR of 5.22
5th:ACR with a WR of 5.29
6th:ACU with a WR of 5.43
7th:AC with a WR of 5.44
8th:ACRo with a WR of 6.39
9th:ACIVFC with a WR of 7.32
10th:ACL with a WR of 8.68
(*WR stands for "weighted rank".I hadn't heard of that before,but it is used by Polldaddy.It is calculated as : (sum of (position*count) for each choice/total responses)+1.Something like an average position)

Some interesting facts:
-While ACIV was crowned victorious,it is tied with ACII regarding the most 1# places,as there is a 32,1% of people who believe that each of them is the best,respectively.Third in tha category lies ACU with 17,9%,with fourth having around 7%.
-The reason why ACIV won is that another 32,1% believes it is the second beat AC,while only a 10,7% believes that AC2 is he second best.Second in that category is ACR with 14,3%
-An amazing 32,1% believes that ACB is the third best AC.
-Finally,almost a 40% of people believs that ACL is the worst game.Second in that category is ACU with a 21,4%,while third is ACIII with 17,9%

Thank you for participating!

The_Kiwi_
01-08-2015, 10:29 AM
I would have expected Rogue to be higher and Unity to be lower
I also expected ACB to be lower

I guess its just the haters that are more vocal :rolleyes:

Bipolar Matt
01-11-2015, 07:08 PM
Best to worst, in my opinion:

1. AC2
2. AC Brotherood
3. AC Black Flag
4. AC Rogue
5. AC Revelations
6. AC3
7. AC original
8. AC Liberation HD

No PS4 yet, so can't weigh in on Unity.