PDA

View Full Version : Troll detector, if you have anything negative opinions please read this thread



freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 06:22 PM
EDIT: I FORGOT TO LABEL AS SPOILERS. IT SHOULDN'T BE TOO BAD BUT JUST IN CASE DO NOT READ. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. mods, please edit title

if you have said negative things about the game i am willing to believe you. simply post a picture here of the boxart with a note on top with your username on it. if you do that i will believe you and take all you say seriously. if you do not then it is proof that you are lying. and no one will believe you.

this thread might seem pointless but let's be honest. if no pictures are posted on this thread we can tell you are simply trolling. this is probably one of the few threads that feeds off inactivity. this thread is here to either prove that your opinion is valid. or to reassure other people who are now doubtful of the game. the end.


i will post the names of the people who have proof they have the game here. so we know who is trolling and who actually has an opinion

RatonhnhakeFan
10-27-2012, 06:27 PM
So negative opinions = trolling and pics have to be posted as proof but positive opinions = undeniable truth? Seriously guys, everyone can have their own opinion on the game. Or a movie. Or a book. etc.

BBALive
10-27-2012, 06:30 PM
So negative opinions = trolling and pics have to be posted as proof but positive opinions = undeniable truth? Seriously guys, everyone can have their own opinion on the game. Or a movie. Or a book. etc.

No, it just makes their opinion valid.

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 06:30 PM
So negative opinions = trolling and pics have to be posted as proof but positive opinions = undeniable truth? Seriously guys, everyone can have their own opinion on the game. Or a movie. Or a book. etc.
read the thread. i want proof that they aren't trolling. i am happy to accept all their opinions whether good or bad. but i want to know whether i can take them seriously or not. if you simply do as the thread asks it will be proof to everyone out there. if no one posts their pictures as proof then we will know they are trolling, and as i only want them to post the box it shouldn't be spoilery at all.

MRNMRSPACER
10-27-2012, 06:39 PM
i have to agree every 1 has their own opinions,a ic of the box + username would validate any opinion for me

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 06:40 PM
<a href="http://s1279.beta.photobucket.com/user/zenguin1/library/" target="_blank"><img src="http://i1279.photobucket.com/albums/y533/zenguin1/ArcSoft_Image15.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"/></a>
erm. pic isn't working, i think you typed something wrong

UrDeviant1
10-27-2012, 06:50 PM
erm. pic isn't working, i think you typed something wrong

f it. don't know how to give an image a URL.

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 06:53 PM
f it. don't know how to give an image a URL.
i'm not sure either. someone else will know though

MarcinTrzaskacz
10-27-2012, 06:59 PM
OMG IT SUXKS! WRSt graPHiXCs EVAr!!!!!!!!!!!!! BLaq OPS 2 Is waY BeetER! I hAvE BLak OATS 2 bCUZ my vBRO wRkS ar GammEsTOP sO HE Gets AlL tHe Gamz EaRaly!!!

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:05 PM
OMG IT SUXKS! WRSt graPHiXCs EVAr!!!!!!!!!!!!! BLaq OPS 2 Is waY BeetER! I hAvE BLak OATS 2 bCUZ my vBRO wRkS ar GammEsTOP sO HE Gets AlL tHe Gamz EaRaly!!!
i have no idea what you are saying

SevereAtrophy
10-27-2012, 07:10 PM
This is UrDeviant1 pic he was trying to post.

http://i1279.photobucket.com/albums/y533/zenguin1/ArcSoft_Image15.jpg

MRNMRSPACER
10-27-2012, 07:10 PM
i have no idea what you are saying
he said
OMG IT SUCKS,WORST GRAPHICS EVER!!! BLACK OPS 2 IS WAY BETTER!!I HAVE BLACK OPS 2 BECAUSE MY BRO WORKS AT GAMESTOP SO HE GETS ALL THE GAMES EARLY!!!

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:11 PM
he said
OMG IT SUCKS,WORST GRAPHICS EVER!!! BLACK OPS 2 IS WAY BETTER!!I HAVE BLACK OPS 2 BECAUSE MY BRO WORKS AT GAMESTOP SO HE GETS ALL THE GAMES EARLY!!!
thank you, sorry i don't understand BULLCRAP

UrDeviant1
10-27-2012, 07:14 PM
Lol thanks, SevereAtrophy!

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:15 PM
Lol thanks, SevereAtrophy!
it's clearly photoshopped... :p

so far everyone is trolling. YAY!

SevereAtrophy
10-27-2012, 07:17 PM
your welcome :cool:

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:31 PM
okay, by the fact that no one has actually done what i asked we can deduce that so far everyone is lying. although a few people will be asleep. by this time to tomorrow we should have our proof as to whether people are trolling or not.

this thread is beautiful if i do say so myself. it's a work of art to create a thread that strives off of people not posting

SevereAtrophy
10-27-2012, 07:32 PM
okay, by the fact that no one has actually done what i asked we can deduce that so far everyone is lying. although a few people will be asleep. by this time to tomorrow we should have our proof as to whether people are trolling or not.

this thread is beautiful if i do say so myself. it's a work of art to create a thread that strives off of people not posting

it is a stroke of genious

MarcinTrzaskacz
10-27-2012, 07:33 PM
Seriously, nobody has to answer to you. If you don't want to believe someone then don't believe them... Simple... As... That.

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:36 PM
Seriously, nobody has to answer to you. If you don't want to believe someone then don't believe them... Simple... As... That.
it's not that i don't want to believe them. it's that i want a valid reason as to why i should believe them. if they are telling the truth they will reply to this thread and do as the thread asks. it's not hard. if they don't post here then we will know they've been trolling and no one will take them seriously. they should be glad i'm giving them a chance to prove they aren't trolling, because many people have already decided that's what they are doing,

FinalJ1
10-27-2012, 07:39 PM
OMG IT SUXKS! WRSt graPHiXCs EVAr!!!!!!!!!!!!! BLaq OPS 2 Is waY BeetER! I hAvE BLak OATS 2 bCUZ my vBRO wRkS ar GammEsTOP sO HE Gets AlL tHe Gamz EaRaly!!!

You do know there are people here that work for GameStop, me being one of them. So I know your a lier, BO2 hasn't shipped from the warehouse. And yes I would know I'm a store manager.

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:42 PM
You do know there are people here that work for GameStop, me being one of them. So I know your a lier, BO2 hasn't shipped from the warehouse. And yes I would know I'm a store manager.
please. i'm begging you. i will give you my address just, please.

BBALive
10-27-2012, 07:54 PM
You do know there are people here that work for GameStop, me being one of them. So I know your a lier, BO2 hasn't shipped from the warehouse. And yes I would know I'm a store manager.

He's obviously joking.

ACfan443
10-27-2012, 07:55 PM
No, it just makes their opinion valid.

You honestly wouldn't question the validity of a positive opinion. Someone says "The game was AMAZING, I LOVED THE ENDING" no one would say "I don't believe you, post a picture to prove you have it." It doesn't make sense. If the person making the claim gives an honest and convincing reason, I see no reason why they should have to validate their opinion with a picture.

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 07:58 PM
You honestly wouldn't question the validity of a positive opinion. Someone says "The game was AMAZING, I LOVED THE ENDING" no one would say "I don't believe you, post a picture to prove you have it." It doesn't make sense. If the person making the claim gives an honest and convincing reason, I see no reason why they should have to validate their opinion with a picture.
why would you troll a good thing?

give me an example of convincing reason. this is the only one i can think of.

ACfan443
10-27-2012, 08:02 PM
why would you troll a good thing?

give me an example of convincing reason. this is the only one i can think of.

I didn't say a good thing. I said if they gave a convincing reason why they think the story/ending is bad, then they shouldn't have to validate their reasons, or be automatically labelled a 'liar'.

Commissar38
10-27-2012, 08:05 PM
Take a Stoic attitude towards negative opinions, namely "I don't care what you think. I like what I like and I know I will personally like this game. I won't let you poison my enjoyment of something just as I wouldn't poison your enjoyment of something."

freddie_1897
10-27-2012, 08:07 PM
I didn't say a good thing. I said if they gave a convincing reason why they think the story/ending is bad, then they shouldn't have to validate their reasons, or be automatically labelled a 'liar'.
their not being labelled a liar. but this is a way for them to prove they are telling the truth. this is the only way to give a convincing reason without spoiling the game for everyone else. when i say giving negative comments i mean if they are saying things like "AC3 is terrible" or "its so disappointing". if they said "it's amazing but..." or something along those lines then fine,

this thread is to reassure the people worried by the negative comments. if they are telling the truth they will post what i've asked. everyone has a camera in some form or another, it's not difficult. but before they tell us how bad the game is i want them to give us proof as to why we should listen to them

freddie_1897
10-29-2012, 09:05 AM
in the light of recent events i feel it necessary to bring this thread back. so far no one has done as requested which is either because they are all trolls or because they just don't know of this thread. which is why i'm bringing it back

Hassassiyin
10-29-2012, 09:28 AM
i have no idea what you are saying

I think he's trying to say he likes black ops 2, sucks his brothers genitals at gamestop and it always makes him "come" early.
Thats what I understood, could be wrong though.

Brownsnakeeyes
10-29-2012, 10:41 AM
Not everyone will like the ending, it's that simple. Don't go by what others say, form your own opinion.

Eurostar7
10-29-2012, 10:48 AM
in the light of recent events i feel it necessary to bring this thread back. so far no one has done as requested which is either because they are all trolls or because they just don't know of this thread. which is why i'm bringing it back

Maybe we arent proving it because we dont want to get banned from the forums. If you havent noticed, the rules have been updated a couple hours ago

http://forums.ubi.com/showthread.php/717088-Important-please-read-SPOILER-WARNING-RULES!-updated-28-10-12

SevereAtrophy
10-29-2012, 10:51 AM
Maybe we arent proving it because we dont want to get banned from the forums. If you havent noticed, the rules have been updated a couple hours ago

http://forums.ubi.com/showthread.php/717088-Important-please-read-SPOILER-WARNING-RULES!-updated-28-10-12

You holding your box is not a spoiler.

Eurostar7
10-29-2012, 10:54 AM
I dont have the game but i seen all the main missions. you either can trust me, or inevitably believe me in a week or 2 when you beat the game yourself.

ACfan443
10-29-2012, 10:59 AM
in the light of recent events i feel it necessary to bring this thread back. so far no one has done as requested which is either because they are all trolls or because they just don't know of this thread. which is why i'm bringing it back

Seriously, no one has to do what you say. A lot of people are basing their judgement from walkthrough videos, so how exactly are they going to prove they have the game and are not trolls? Quite a few people are popping up with very similar opinions, I can't imagine that they're all lying trolls.

SevereAtrophy
10-29-2012, 11:04 AM
Seriously, no one has to do what you say. A lot of people are basing their judgement from walkthrough videos, so how exactly are they going to prove they have the game and are not trolls? Quite a few people are popping up with very similar opinions, I can't imagine that they're all lying trolls.

Wouldn't surprise me if they were. People get kicks out of annoying people on forums.

ApexMandalorian
10-29-2012, 04:18 PM
why would you troll a good thing?

give me an example of convincing reason. this is the only one i can think of.

If you ABSOLUTELY want your proof of whether the game is amazing or terrible, BEFORE the game releases, just go on Youtube and spoil yourself. Then make your judgment. I guarantee you that's what the majority of these so-called trolls are doing. Otherwise, wait a day. The reason you aren't getting any responses to your OP is because your OP gives the impression of a guy whose pissed that there are people who didn't like the ending of the game, who had something negative to say about the game when for the past months there as almost universally been positive views of the game. The fact is, IF you really want proof, you should want proof either way: positive or negative. Your OP should have been this: "For anyone who has ANYTHING to say about the AC3 story and/or ending, positive or negative, post a pic of your name and the game box". But you know what, you don't have to do even that. All people have to do is go to someone's Youtube page who leaked it, take out the actual link and channel/user name, and post a pic with the thumbnails of the different leaked videos of AC3. THAT is your proof that there are people who have seen the game and the ending.

freddie_1897
10-29-2012, 05:30 PM
If you ABSOLUTELY want your proof of whether the game is amazing or terrible, BEFORE the game releases, just go on Youtube and spoil yourself. Then make your judgment. I guarantee you that's what the majority of these so-called trolls are doing. Otherwise, wait a day.
This thread is NOT for finding proof of whether the game is amazing or terrible. and i'm not doing this for my own personal judgement. i made this thread as a way people could prove that they have a valid point and aren't just trolling WITHOUT spoiling it for the rest of us. now while i may be able to form my own opinion in a day or two their are others, specifically PC gamers, who don't have that privilege, and don't want to spoil it for themselves. i'll admit that at the time of making this thread i did not realise most of the people with negative opinions were watching walkthroughs, i assumed that they got the game early as a result of stores breaking release date.


The reason you aren't getting any responses to your OP is because your OP gives the impression of a guy whose pissed that there are people who didn't like the ending of the game, who had something negative to say about the game when for the past months there as almost universally been positive views of the game.
again, this is not meant as a thread to help people form an opinion, this is a thread to help people know who's opinion is trustworthy, i'm sure most people with negative views are trustworthy and i have zero problem with their negative views. i have a problem with the few people who actually are trolling because it's using false opinion to sway people's judgement. i'm sorry if the OP makes me seem like a oissed of old man as i didn't mean it that way.




The fact is, IF you really want proof, you should want proof either way: positive or negative. Your OP should have been this: "For anyone who has ANYTHING to say about the AC3 story and/or ending, positive or negative, post a pic of your name and the game box"
i'll admit it was a mistake to do that. i actually realised this after making the thread. at the time i assumed i'd make it prioritising people with negative opinions as if you were a troll you would be making negative posts. i have yet to find a troll who says "YES AC3 IS AWESOMEME, OMG" or something along those lines. but afterwards i realised that this thread shouldn't have been directed at trolls only. as many people could have made positive comments with no proof to back them up as they are simply fanboys of the franchise. so in that scenario, yes, my mistake.


But you know what, you don't have to do even that. All people have to do is go to someone's Youtube page who leaked it, take out the actual link and channel/user name, and post a pic with the thumbnails of the different leaked videos of AC3. THAT is your proof that there are people who have seen the game and the ending.
that is an idea but that is a problem because anyone can do that. i could do that right now without having watched any of the videos. however when i made this thread i hadn't taken into account the people who had simply watched the walkthroughs rather than played the game themselves. and so yes, those people do have a valid opinion, but only on the story. Gameplay wise you need to have the game or at least have played it to form your own opinion. all in all this thread can find trolls who have been trolling on gameplay aspects but not story aspects which is a flaw that i only have myself to blame. so i am willing to ask a mod to get this thread locked if thats what people think is best.